Printing across borders? It would appear not!
Firstly it would be a good idea to read my blog ‘Fogra 51 and 52 profiles do not match ISO 12647/2 2013 which is still true apart from the last paragraph!
The aim by the ISO TC130 committee, which is responsible for all ISO printing standards, to align the ISO 12647/ 2013 for paper types PS1 and PS5, coated and uncoated, to the figures in Fogra 51 and 52 data sets ad the associated ICC profiles has been rejected by the committee.
This refusal to change the CIE Lab values for the white paper points was from the US and Japanese delegations, which pointed out that the papers used in these regions matched the 2013 version of the standard rather then the revised figures from Fogra.
Fogra with the Fogra 51 and 52-based profiles had revised the white paper CIE Lab figures to reflect the brighter white papers, with the high OBA (optical brightens/fluorescents) used in European papers.
So were does international printing standardisation go now. Has it spilt into regions?
Well, yes it has, but the US has always taken a differing course to Europe with its G7 process control methods and profiles, and Japan and the Far East use Japan Color. Both are based on the ISO 12647/2 2013 figures and tolerances but use differing ICC profiles and process control methods.
The implications to an individual printer or client will depend on the scope of their activities across these regions. So the main area for concern is likely to be the large multi-nationals and brands that print in across all regions.
So will there be a need prepare production print ready files for these regions using the ICC profiles for each area and region?
Lets consider wood-free coated papers, called PS1 by ISO 12647/2 2013:
Europe would require profiles based on Fogra 39 or 51. For Web Offset you may need to supply files to a Fogra 45 profile, PSO LWC improved.
In the USA the GRACol/SWOP 2013 profiles from Idealliance will be used. These are based on the 7 CRPC color data sets in ISO 15339/CGATS 21 specifications.
Indeed the GRACol2013_CRPC6.icc profile could be considered a good match to the requirements of ISO 12647/2 2013, apart from the TVI curves not matching the new ones in ISO 12647/2 2013.
The latest Japan Color profile for PS1 coated papers seems to be based on ISO 12647/2 2004 Amd 1, JapanColor2011Coated.icc. Please let me know if there is going to be a 2013 based version.
So practically what difference would be noticed if using, say a Fogra 51 based profile in the US without it being repurposed, or indeed, any other profile and regional combination? Then factor in the older profiles based on the 2004 Amd 1 version of the standard and there are a lot more cross regionally, cross standard combinations.
I looked at this when the beta versions of the Fogra 51 profiles were released. I took 4 test images and converted them to:
ISO coated v2 300
A Fogra 39 high GCR profile
Fogra 51 beta
See image below:
This was then contract proofed to Fogra 39. On examination, yes, very small differences could be seen between the differing separations/profiles, but if that difference had been within a print run, most would be happy.
So for many markets there may not be a need to produce multiply regional versions or reprocess files in workflows or colour servers to maintain a reasonable common colour appearance across regions.
So I guess the message to printers and clients is proof and test images that may need to be used when ‘Printing Across Borders’ in order to decide if images need to be re-purposed for differing regions.
- Paul Sherfield who runs the consultancy is well known in the printing and pre-media industry as having considerable knowledge on digital workflows, with a special expertise on the business reasoning behind such systems.
He has installed some of the most successful digital pre-press and pre media systems in the UK. For 2 years he worked on a number of medium term projects before starting the consultancy in July 2000. Before this he was a partner in what became one of the leading pre-press/printing companies in London.
He is active in a number of industry groups including the BPIF Technical Standards Committee, ISO TC 130 printing standards committees and is chair of the BPIF steering group for ISO 12647/2 UK certification, He is a regular speaker at seminars and conferences.